Below average
The deck wins 26% of its games – the average at a four-player table is 25%.
- Tier · Elo
- C 1438 #49 of 64 in the rankings up to €1,500
- Win rate
- 26% 34 wins in 130 games, 90% certain between 20 and 33%
- Placements
- 125%10×
- 225%10×
- 322%9×
- 428%11×
Create a new deck there and paste the list when importing.
- Price
- €415.23of €1,500.00
- Games
- 130in 13 tournaments
- Cards
- 10036 lands, 14 basic
- Game Changer
- 2at most 3 allowed
- Combos
- 4complete in the deck
- Rules check
- Passed100 cards, colors, banlist
At most €1,500 including the commander. If prices rise above that, the shopping list is rebuilt automatically.
Strengths and weaknesses
From 90 analysed games in 9 tournaments (with the lists played in the tournament). Games that hit the time limit don't count, just like in the rankings. Values in brackets: average of all decks in the same price class. Hover over or tap a point to see the exact numbers.
Play style: wins through combat – 100% of the damage to opponents is combat damage · How it wins: 62% of wins by surviving (knocked out at most one opponent itself, the others took each other out) – all-deck avg: 35%
Strengths
No clear strength in the logs.
Weaknesses
- Little pressure certainonly avg 18 damage to opponents per game (all-deck avg: 29) · 90 games
- Slow to win certainwins on average only on its 13th own turn (all-deck avg: 12th) · 24 wins
- Rarely eliminates opponents certain0.40 per game on average (all-deck avg: 0.62) · 90 games
- Attacks often get blocked certain24% of attackers blocked (all-deck avg: 17%) · 843 attackers in 90 games
Commander (2)
- Frodo, Adventurous Hobbit€0.33
- Sam, Loyal AttendantCombo€0.50
Creatures (37)
- Esper Sentinel Card draw€39.03
- Delighted Halfling Ramp€21.20
- Warren Soultrader RampCombo€15.12
- Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff Ramp€9.18
- Bilbo, Fellow Conspirator Ramp€9.12
- Ygra, Eater of AllCombo€8.53
- The Gaffer Card draw€8.46
- Academy Manufactor RampCombo€6.91
- Chatterfang, Squirrel GeneralCombo€6.76
- Experimental ConfectionerCombo€5.46
- Essence WardenCombo€3.70
- Elanor Gardner Ramp€3.24
- Treebeard, Gracious Host€3.12
- Birds of Paradise Ramp€3.00
- Belladonna Took Card draw€2.79
- Farmer Cotton€2.35
- Tireless Provisioner Ramp€2.01
- Cauldron FamiliarCombo€1.67
- Samwise GamgeeCombo€1.59
- Rapacious Guest€1.32
- The Sackville-Bagginses Ramp€1.15
- Pippin, Warden of Isengard€0.93
- Feasting Hobbit€0.76
- Gilded Goose Ramp€0.62
- Banquet Guests€0.58
- Gwaihir, Greatest of the Eagles€0.54
- Gollum, Obsessed Stalker€0.42
- Mirkwood Bats€0.40
- Lobelia, Defender of Bag End€0.39
- Merry, Warden of Isengard€0.39
- Prize Pig Ramp€0.32
- Peregrin Took Card drawCombo€0.23
- Prosperous Innkeeper RampCombo€0.14
- Rosie Cotton of South Lane€0.13
- Savvy Hunter Card drawCombo€0.09
- Meriadoc Brandybuck€0.08
- Shire Shirriff Removal€0.08
Instants (7)
- Heroic Intervention Protection€8.73
- Anguished Unmaking Removal€1.86
- Assassin's Trophy Removal€1.20
- Path to Exile Removal€1.00
- Swords to Plowshares Removal€0.94
- Go for the Throat Removal€0.59
- Mortify Removal€0.12
Sorceries (8)
- Toxic Deluge Board wipeAI can't play€3.97
- The Battle of Bywater Board wipe€2.63
- Farseek RampAI weak€0.61
- Night's Whisper Card draw€0.42
- Dusk // Dawn Board wipe€0.24
- Cultivate Ramp€0.20
- Revive the Shire€0.10
- Many Partings€0.06
Artifacts (6)
- The One Ring ProtectionGame Changer€104.30
- Nuka-Cola Vending Machine RampCombo€18.97
- Well of Lost Dreams Card drawAI weak€1.11
- Sol Ring Ramp€0.85
- Arcane Signet Ramp€0.39
- Field-Tested Frying Pan€0.26
Enchantments (4)
- Smothering Tithe RampGame Changer€32.60
- Call of the Ring Card draw€4.08
- Sanguine BondAI weak€4.01
- Of Herbs and Stewed Rabbit Card draw€0.72
Lands (36)
- Verdant Catacombs€24.37
- Windswept Heath€10.36
- Godless Shrine€7.32
- Overgrown Tomb€7.08
- Temple Garden€6.06
- The Shire€2.01
- Woodland Cemetery€0.90
- Brushland€0.81
- Necroblossom Snarl€0.63
- Access Tunnel€0.55
- Murmuring Bosk€0.33
- Isolated Chapel€0.32
- Sunpetal Grove€0.28
- Canopy Vista€0.22
- Shineshadow Snarl€0.22
- Command Tower€0.21
- Exotic Orchard€0.18
- Sandsteppe Citadel€0.18
- Fortified Village€0.17
- Rogue's Passage€0.17
- Scattered Groves€0.15
- Path of Ancestry€0.11
- 5× Plains
- 4× Swamp
- 5× Forest
Combos in the deck (4)
Detected from the decklist (Commander Spellbook): theoretically possible, see Spellbook for requirements. Whether a combo actually came together in games is shown in the “Games” tab.
- Warren Soultrader + … → Infinite artifact ETB, Infinite artifact LTB, Infinite artifact sacrifice triggers
7 versions, each with one of: Chatterfang, Squirrel General · Cauldron Familiar · Academy Manufactor · Peregrin Took · Prosperous Innkeeper · Essence Warden and 1 more - Peregrin Took + … → Infinite card draw, Infinite draw triggers, Near-infinite tapped Treasure tokens
2 versions, each with one of: Nuka-Cola Vending Machine · Experimental Confectioner - Ygra, Eater of All + Experimental Confectioner + Savvy Hunter → Infinite card draw, Near-infinite creature ETB, Infinite draw triggers
- Sam, Loyal Attendant + Warren Soultrader + Academy Manufactor + Experimental Confectioner → Infinite artifact tokens, Infinite creature LTB, Infinite creature ETB
Commander Spellbook lists 11 entries because every version counts separately (for example with a different sacrifice outlet). Here each combo counts once.
Show all 11 entries
- Peregrin Took + Nuka-Cola Vending Machine → Infinite card draw, Infinite draw triggers, Near-infinite tapped Treasure tokens
- Peregrin Took + Experimental Confectioner → Infinite card draw, Infinite draw triggers, Near-infinite creature tokens
- Chatterfang, Squirrel General + Warren Soultrader + Academy Manufactor → Infinite artifact ETB, Infinite artifact LTB, Infinite artifact sacrifice triggers
- Chatterfang, Squirrel General + Warren Soultrader + Peregrin Took → Infinite artifact ETB, Infinite artifact LTB, Infinite artifact sacrifice triggers
- Ygra, Eater of All + Experimental Confectioner + Savvy Hunter → Infinite card draw, Near-infinite creature ETB, Infinite draw triggers
- Warren Soultrader + Cauldron Familiar + Academy Manufactor → Infinite artifact ETB, Infinite artifact LTB, Infinite artifact sacrifice triggers
- Warren Soultrader + Cauldron Familiar + Peregrin Took → Infinite artifact ETB, Infinite artifact LTB, Infinite artifact sacrifice triggers
- Warren Soultrader + Chatterfang, Squirrel General + Prosperous Innkeeper → Infinite artifact ETB, Infinite artifact LTB, Infinite artifact sacrifice triggers
- Warren Soultrader + Essence Warden + Chatterfang, Squirrel General → Infinite artifact ETB, Infinite artifact LTB, Infinite artifact sacrifice triggers
- Warren Soultrader + Cauldron Familiar + Samwise Gamgee → Infinite artifact ETB, Infinite artifact LTB, Infinite artifact sacrifice triggers
- Sam, Loyal Attendant + Warren Soultrader + Academy Manufactor + Experimental Confectioner → Infinite artifact tokens, Infinite creature LTB, Infinite creature ETB
Adjusted for the Forge AI
The list above is the best tested version, the way you would play it in real games. The Forge AI can't play a few cards – they were replaced in the tournament (the deck builder also rearranges other slots within the budget). The win rate comes from games with these replacements; the original cards themselves were not tested by the AI.
- Shire Shirriff: swapped for a test
- Toxic Deluge: AI can't play it
- Deadly Rollick: test
- Fell the Mighty: replacement
The games in numbers
- Commander cast
- 100%of games, by turn 4 in 84%
- Damage per game
- 18average: 29
- Wins on average
- turn 13own turn, average: 11.6
- First one out
- 32%29 of 90 games, average: 25%
- Too few lands
- 6%of games, 1 of them won, average: 8%
- Mulligans
- 7%6 in 90 games, average: 9%
Cards with a measurable effect
A correlation, not proof: these cards were cast clearly more often in wins.
- Mirkwood Bats – won 71% of the games in which it was cast (17), otherwise 16%
- Meriadoc Brandybuck – won 56% of the games in which it was cast (16), otherwise 20%
- Gilded Goose – won 50% of the games in which it was cast (18), otherwise 21%
What the games show
From 90 analysed games in 9 tournaments (with the lists played in the tournament). Games that hit the time limit don't count, just like in the rankings. Values in brackets: average of all decks in the same price class. “certain”: recorded in the game log. “hint”: keeps showing up, but is no proof.
Forge AI note: This deck wins remarkably often by surviving. The Forge AI rarely attacks players with a high life total and hardly removes win-the-game cards – at a real table, where people go after it earlier, it is probably weaker than measured here. Details
Damage per game all games
Total damage to opponents ÷ all 90 games – what the card contributes over the whole test
- Sam, Loyal Attendant avg 4.1hit in 59 of 90 games
- Ygra, Eater of All avg 2.6hit in 9 of 90 games
- Feasting Hobbit avg 2.2hit in 8 of 90 games
Damage when used when it hits
Total damage ÷ games in which the card dealt damage – its strength when used
- Ygra, Eater of All avg 26.4hit in 9 of 90 games
- Sam, Loyal Attendant avg 6.2hit in 59 of 90 games
- Mirkwood Bats avg 4.4hit in 11 of 90 games
Top finishers eliminates opponents
Cards that most often knocked an opposing commander out of the game
- Feasting Hobbit 5×90 games in deck
- Halfling Token 5×90 games in deck
- Ygra, Eater of All 5×90 games in deck
Best interaction answers threats
Opposing cards destroyed, exiled, bounced or countered when this card resolved (tokens excluded)
- Fell the Mighty 81×avg 0.9 per game · 90 games in deck
- Dusk 30×avg 0.3 per game · 90 games in deck
- The Battle of Bywater 27×avg 0.3 per game · 90 games in deck
Biggest walls blocks the most
Opposing cards that blocked this deck's attackers most often – 24% of 843 attackers blocked in total, 6% of those by flyers or reach
- Zombie Token 23×blocked in 4 games
- Cloud of Faeries 3×blocked in 3 games
- Esper Sentinel 3×blocked in 3 games
Rarely cast candidates to cut
Cards in this list that were cast least often in their games – often too expensive or too slow (lands excluded)
- Arcane Signet 7%cast in 6 of 90 games
- Nuka-Cola Vending Machine 8%cast in 7 of 90 games
- Sanguine Bond 8%cast in 7 of 90 games
Wins by turn speed
On which own turn the 24 wins came
- by turn 70%
- turns 8–921%
- turns 10–1129%
- turns 12–138%
- turn 14+42%
Combos in play certain Peregrin Took + Nuka-Cola Vending Machine: all pieces cast in 4 games, 2 won · Peregrin Took + Experimental Confectioner: all pieces cast in 3 games, 0 won · Chatterfang, Squirrel General + Warren Soultrader + Academy Manufactor: all pieces cast in 2 games, 1 won · Chatterfang, Squirrel General + Warren Soultrader + Peregrin Took: all pieces cast in 1 games, 0 won
Elo history
Elo after every tournament, oldest on the left. Dashed: tier limits S, A, B, C.
Now 1438, highest 1474 (11/10), lowest 1429 – from 13 tournaments.
Recent games
Place in every 4-player game, oldest on the left: gold = win, silver = 2nd, bronze = 3rd, red = 4th, ring = draw.
4144342314143442111321214221422331324323In the last 40 games 10× win, 10× 2nd, 9× 3rd and 11× 4th.
Mana curve without lands
Average 2.63
Roles in the deck
Count / target from the EDHREC average deck (the line), red means clearly below. Strategy: the remaining cards without one of these roles, such as the creatures and effects the deck is built around. 62 non-land cards in total.
Card types
- Creatures38%37
- Instants7%7
- Sorceries8%8
- Artifacts6%6
- Enchantments4%4
- Lands37%36
Most expensive cards
What the program has learned
Each tournament the deck tests one card. A verdict needs at least 40 games with and without the card. Since the deck is rebuilt every tournament with current prices and data, tested cards can drop out again later.
No swap has enough games for a verdict yet.
3 more tested cards are still collecting games.
Shopping list for Cardmarket
Copy the list, create a new list under “Wants” on Cardmarket and paste it.
Total €415.23 Cardmarket average as of Nov 19, 2026
Open Cardmarket WantsPrices without shipping. Individual cards may have become cheaper or more expensive on Cardmarket.
Played by the Forge AI, four players per game. An average deck wins 25%. How are decks tested?
